Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap Cost in 2027: Which Is Cheaper?

Older couple comparing two stacks of paperwork with a calculator at a kitchen table

Medicare Advantage usually costs less in a year when you stay healthy. Medigap usually costs less in a year when you get sick. The right choice depends on which of those risks you would rather carry, and on whether you can still qualify for Medigap.

Written by James O’Neal, licensed Medicare agent and broker. Reviewed November 22, 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Everyone pays the Part B premium, which is $209.40 a month in 2027, whichever option you choose.
  • Medicare Advantage trades a low or $0 premium for copays and a yearly out-of-pocket limit.
  • Medigap Plan G costs more each month but leaves you with very few bills after the $292 Part B deductible.
  • Your first six months on Part B is the safest time to buy Medigap. After that, health questions can apply in most states.

Video: Which costs less when you are sick?

James compares what Medicare Advantage and Medigap can cost in a year when you need significant care. (9 min)

The two ways to pay for Medicare

With Medicare Advantage, a private plan covers your Part A and Part B care, usually with drug coverage built in. You pay copays as you use care, up to a yearly out-of-pocket limit that each plan sets within a federal maximum. Most plans have networks.

With Original Medicare plus Medigap, Medicare pays first and the Medigap policy pays most of what is left. You add a separate Part D plan for drugs. There is no network, so any doctor or hospital in the country that accepts Medicare will take you.

What you pay with each option in 2027

Medicare Advantage

  • Part B premium: $209.40 a month for most people
  • Plan premium: often $0, sometimes more
  • Copays for doctor visits, specialists, hospital stays and other services
  • A yearly in-network out-of-pocket limit, which varies by plan
  • Drug costs, capped at $2,400 a year in 2027

Original Medicare with Medigap Plan G and Part D

  • Part B premium: $209.40 a month for most people
  • Medigap premium: often about $100 to $300 or more a month, depending on your age, ZIP code, tobacco use and the company
  • The $292 Part B deductible, once a year
  • A Part D premium and drug costs, capped at $2,400 a year in 2027
  • Very little else for Medicare-covered care

A healthy year compared with a hard year

Here is a simple example. The numbers are for illustration only. Your actual premiums and limits depend on the plans in your county. Both options include the same Part B premium, so it is left out of the comparison.

Say an Advantage plan has a $0 premium and a $5,000 in-network out-of-pocket limit, and a Medigap Plan G policy costs $180 a month, or $2,160 a year.

  • A healthy year with a few doctor visits and lab tests: the Advantage plan might cost a few hundred dollars in copays. Plan G costs $2,160 in premiums plus the $292 deductible, about $2,452. Advantage wins.
  • A hard year with a hospital stay, surgery and follow-up care: the Advantage plan could reach its $5,000 limit. Plan G still costs about $2,452. Medigap wins by more than $2,500.

The question to ask yourself is which bill you would rather risk: a higher, steady premium every month, or a lower premium with the chance of a bigger bill in a bad year.

Costs that are easy to miss

  • Networks. An HMO plan generally will not pay for non-emergency care outside its network, so a favorite specialist or hospital can turn into a large bill.
  • Prior authorization. Advantage plans often require approval before certain tests, procedures and hospital stays.
  • Travel. Medigap works anywhere in the U.S. that accepts Medicare. Advantage plans usually cover only emergencies and urgent care outside the service area.
  • Medigap premium increases. Medigap premiums usually rise with age and over time, so compare companies, not just plan letters.
  • Extra benefits. Many Advantage plans include dental, vision, hearing or an over-the-counter allowance that Medigap does not. Count them only if you will actually use them.

Why timing matters more than price

You can usually switch from one Advantage plan to another every fall. Getting into Medigap is different. Your best chance is your Medigap open enrollment period, the six months starting with the month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During that window, a company cannot refuse you or charge more because of your health.

After that, in most states, a company can ask health questions and decline you. There are exceptions, such as a trial right if you joined Medicare Advantage when you first got Medicare, or a plan that leaves your area. If your Advantage plan is ending for 2027, read what to do if your Medicare Advantage plan is dropped.

Which option tends to fit

  • Medicare Advantage often fits people on a tight monthly budget, people whose doctors are in a local plan’s network, and people who value extra benefits like dental and vision.
  • Medigap often fits people with ongoing health conditions, people who travel or live in two states, and people who want to see specialists without referrals or network limits.
  • Veterans should also consider how either option works with VA health care.

Learn more about Medicare Supplement plans or Medicare Advantage plans.

Common questions

Which is cheaper, Medicare Advantage or Medigap?

In a healthy year, Medicare Advantage is usually cheaper because many plans have a $0 premium. In a year with a hospital stay or ongoing treatment, Medigap is often cheaper because Plan G leaves you paying little beyond the Part B deductible, while an Advantage plan can cost up to its out-of-pocket limit.

Is Medigap worth it if I am healthy right now?

It can be. The best time to buy Medigap is your first six months on Part B, when companies cannot turn you down or charge more for health reasons. If you wait until you are sick, you may not be able to get it.

Can I switch from Medicare Advantage to Medigap later?

Sometimes, but it is not automatic. In most states, after your first Medigap open enrollment, a company can ask health questions and decline you. Exceptions include a trial right if you tried Medicare Advantage for the first time, or your plan leaving your area. A few states give extra chances to switch.

Can I have Medigap and Medicare Advantage at the same time?

Not in a useful way. A Medigap policy does not pay anything while you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, and it is against federal law for a company to sell you a Medigap policy if you are in Medicare Advantage, unless you are switching back to Original Medicare. If you join an Advantage plan, talk with an agent before you drop your Medigap policy.

Does Medigap cover prescriptions?

No. Medigap policies sold today do not include drug coverage, so you add a Part D plan. Most Medicare Advantage plans include drug coverage. In 2027, Part D out-of-pocket drug costs are capped at $2,400 a year either way.

What is the difference between Medigap Plan G and Plan N?

Plan G covers everything Original Medicare leaves behind except the Part B deductible. Plan N usually has a lower premium, but you pay small copays for some office and emergency visits, and it does not cover Part B excess charges.

Check this information independently

See Medicare’s pages on when you can buy Medigap and Medicare costs, or call 1-800-MEDICARE. Free counseling is available from your State Health Insurance Assistance Program.

PERSONAL GUIDANCE · NO ADDITIONAL FEE

See both options side by side for your ZIP code

We will price represented Medigap plans and compare them with the Medicare Advantage plans in your county, using your doctors and prescriptions.